Important Note:
This information is not intended to be a substitute for
professional advice, but it may help you understand EMDR
and work with a professional to make an informed decision
about whether EMDR therapy is right for you.
How does EMDR therapy work?
At the time of a traumatic event, strong emotions interfere
with our ability to completely process the experience and one
moment becomes “frozen in time.” Recalling
the traumatic event may feel as though the person is reliving
the event all over again because the images, smells, sounds,
and feelings are still there and can be triggered in the present. When
activated, these memories cause a negative impact on our daily
functioning and interfere with the way we see ourselves, our
world and how we relate to others. EMDR therapy appears
to directly effect the brain, allowing the individual to resume
normal functioning while no longer reliving the images, sounds,
and feelings associated with the trauma. The memory is
still there, but it is less upsetting.
Trapped by Memories: How a single trauma can impact our
lives
Francine Shapiro, the creator of EMDR, uses the example
of a rape survivor to illustrate how people can get “trapped” by
memories of trauma. While a woman who has been raped might
intellectually know that she’s not to blame, but she
still may feel emotions of guilt and shame surrounding the
attack. Her memory of the rape is then forever affected by
these emotions, which she hasn’t fully explored or
dealt with. Shapiro believes that as time goes by, “when
the individual thinks about the trauma, or when the memory
is triggered by similar situations, the person may feel like
she is reliving it, or may experience strong emotions and
physical sensations.” (Source: EMDR.com)
Unlike many forms of talk therapy, an EMDR therapist helps
trauma survivors by linking what was seen, felt, heard and
believed at the time of the trauma with a unique, additional
element: a pattern of rapid directional eye movements induced
by the therapist waving one or two fingers back and forth in
front of the client’s eyes. Typically this is done
at a distance of 12” or more. There are other
forms of dual processing, such as tactile sensations or audio
processing. The client is gently guided to just notice
what comes up without trying to control the content while processing
the information until it is less and less disturbing. Overtime
the disturbing memory and associated beliefs, feelings, sensations
become “digested” or worked through until it is
associated with a positive belief about the self. For
example, “I am a failure” becomes “I can
succeed.”
Similar to many forms of psychotherapy, the exact mechanism
for the effectiveness of EMDR is yet unknown. It appears
that using rapid eye movements relieves the anxiety associated
with the trauma so that the original event can be examined
from a more detached perspective, somewhat like watching a
movie of what happened. Some experts have noted that the eye
movements involved in EMDR might be similar to what occurs
naturally during dreaming or REM (rapid eye movement) sleep. It
may be thought of as a physiologically based therapy that allows
a person to see material in a new and less distressing way. Others
believe it reactivates parts of the brain that were “shut
down” as a coping mechanism. In this way cognitive
reorganizing takes place, allowing the negative, painful
emotions to give way to more resolved, empowered feelings.
Steps of an EMDR therapy session
EMDR Step #1: History and treatment planning
If you choose to try EMDR therapy, your first session will
likely involve the therapist taking an initial client history.
The therapist will probably ask you about the problems, behaviors,
and fears that have provoked you to try therapy. However, one
difference between EMDR and many other therapies is that you
don’t need to discuss traumatic events in detail. The
emotions and physical sensations surrounding the event are
what’s important, not the details about the event itself.
Once the therapist has developed a treatment plan for you based
on this initial assessment, the process of EMDR can begin.
EMDR Step #2: Preparation
The preparation stage involves the therapist teaching you
some self-care techniques, so that you can handle strong emotions
that may arise during or between sessions. EMDR places a strong
emphasis on self-care. This stage is also important for developing
a sense of trust with the therapist. He or she will explain
the theory of EMDR in more detail, and talk about what you
can expect in the following sessions.
EMDR Step #3: Assessment
In the next few sessions, the therapist will ask you to identify
three things:
- A target - the visual image of a traumatic
memory and the associated emotions and bodily sensations.
You probably will have already discussed your target in your
first session, but at this point you will clarify the visual "scene" or "picture" related
to the trauma you experienced. You'll also be asked to rate
the intensity of the sensations you feel when you focus on
this target.
- A negative belief about yourself related
to the memory, which you will rate depending on how true
you feel this belief to be
- A preferred positive belief about yourself.
EMDR Steps #4 & 5: Reprocessing, Desensitization and
Installation
Once you’ve identified the target, negative belief,
and preferred positive belief, the therapist will help you
recall the target image while leading you through a series
of rapid eye movements (or audio or tactile processing and
or a combination there of). This is known as dual processing,
which enables you to access positive ways of reframing the
original trauma (reprocessing), and to release the body’s
stored negative emotional charges around it (desensitization).
The goal is that you’ll then be able to recall the traumatic
event without the anxiety or sadness you once experienced,
thereby “digesting” the trauma until it no longer
holds a “negative charge.”
After each set of rapid eye movements, the therapist will
check in with you and will later assess your level of disturbance
regarding the target image. During this process, you
will continue to “digest” or process the feelings,
images and beliefs that occurred in relation to the trauma
target. You’ll be asked again, to rate the negative
and later positive self-beliefs surrounding your trauma target
which gives the therapist concrete measures of how you are
progressing.
What is unique about EMDR is how rapidly new beliefs about
the self and interpretations of the trauma replace old beliefs.
New possibilities emerge that were never before considered.
These new insights are used as the starting points for the
next set of eye movements, continually helping you to process
the trauma in a healthier, more manageable ways. EMDR therapists
also monitor their clients’ reports on the intensity
of their symptoms between sessions to ensure that progress
is being made and maintained.
EMDR Step 6: Body scan
After being able to replace your negative beliefs surrounding
the trauma with the preferred positive belief, the next step
is to focus on any physical sensations in the body that may
have emerged. The therapist will ask you to think of your original
target and concentrate on your body, noticing any tension or
other sensations that may occur. Once the trauma has been worked
through, you may notice positive bodily sensations that replace
the negative ones originally noted when the session began. EMDR
practitioners believe that there is a “physical response
to unresolved thoughts”. In other words, emotional pain
can manifest itself as physical pain and by changing our beliefs
we may also change the way our body reacts to our thoughts.
In order for EMDR therapy to be successful, the goal is for
you to be able to think or talk about the original target without
feeling any body tension. According to the EMDR
Network, “positive self-beliefs are important, but
they have to be believed on more than just an intellectual
level.”
EMDR Steps #7: Closure
One of the goals of an EMDR session is for you to leave feeling
better than you did before you got there. There may be times
the self-care and calming techniques taught in the preparation
phase may be used in session and will be recommended between
sessions. In EMDR, the client is the one in control and
using techniques such as journaling or imagery helps to provide
a sense of mastery between sessions.
EMDR Step 8: Reevaluation
At the onset of the next session, your therapist will assess
the positive belief and or level of disturbance regarding the
initial target to insure consistency with the final processing
of the last session. This is initiated to assure that
positive results have been maintained, and to note if any additional
processing has occurred, or to determine if there is a need
for additional reprocessing.
EMDR often leads people to feel better very quickly, but
it is important to experience the entire 8-phase process with
a qualified EMDR therapist to ensure the most beneficial results.
Reported benefits and drawbacks of EMDR
EMDR therapy is relatively new – it was developed 20
years ago in 1987, and as a result, the scientific community
continues to examine the long-term results of EMDR. While there
are differing ideas on how effective this treatment really
is, the main benefit of EMDR is the speed at which
deep-seated problems can be resolved. Single sessions
of EMDR have been shown to produce results, and Dr. Francine
Shapiro reported an average treatment time of five sessions
to comprehensively treat people with post traumatic stress
disorder (Shapiro, 1989 199-223).
The following is a list of reported benefits and drawbacks,
to help you make your own decisions regarding EMDR.
Potential Benefits |
Potential
Drawbacks |
-
EMDR does not require the client
to go into detail about the distressing events of
the past.
Unlike many “talk” therapies, there
is no need to analyze the trauma for long periods
of time.
-
EMDR is a multi-faceted approach.The
fact that it simultaneously works on mind, body,
and emotions may account for its success in taking
mere intellectual understanding of the origins of
a problem (e.g. “I know I have guilt over killing
in the war”) to a resolution where post-traumatic
symptoms such as intrusive thoughts, nightmares,
and anger outbursts clear up.
-
The trauma that must be re-experienced
during treatment is relatively short-lived. Cognitive
reprocessing occurs simultaneously with memory
recall.
|
- EMDR was created for use as a trauma therapy
and as such focuses on intensely stressful subjects.
Pregnant women, or those with heart conditions or eye
problems, should consult their health care practitioners
before beginning EMDR therapy.
- EMDR has not been proven effective in studies on
phobias, panic disorder or stress related disorders,
only on PTSD.
- EMDR is a relatively new therapy and as such the
verdict is still out as to its long-term effectiveness.
|
Research on EMDR
There is a divergence of opinion within the scientific community
regarding the efficacy of EMDR compared to other specific forms
of therapy. Those on either side of the debate are passionate
about their claims, and present plenty of food for thought.
However, the number of studies performed is prolific and makes
a statement about EMDR’s impact. According to Gary
Peterson, M.D. EMDR has had “more double-blind,
placebo-controlled studies published in peer-reviewed journals
than any other psychotherapy method” for the treatment
of PTSD. Based on the encouraging results of these studies,
in 1999, both the American Psychological Association and the
International Society of Traumatic Stress Studies approved
EMDR as a valid therapy for post-traumatic stress disorder.
Finding an EMDR therapist
EMDR is a highly specialized therapy that needs to be conducted
by a licensed mental health professional who has taken specific
training in this complex approach. Due to the relative newness
of this therapy, some clinicians may not have received appropriate
training. Also, they may be inexperienced in the actual practice
of EMDR, or be out-of-date with the latest developments in
the therapy.
The EMDR
Network suggests asking any prospective EMDR clinician
the following questions, to ensure you will receive proper
care:
Questions to Ask a Potential EMDR Therapist
- Have you received both Part 1 and 2 of the basic training?
- Was your training program approved by EMDRIA or EMDR
Europe?
- Have you kept up to date about the latest protocols and
developments?
- How many people with my particular problems or disorder
have you successfully treated?
- What is your success rate?
- Are you doing standard EMDR as it is (a) described in
Dr. Shapiro's text, and (b) been tested in research?
- Will you discuss with me the way EMDR can deal with my
obvious symptoms?
- Will you also discuss with me the ways EMDR can be used
to help me live a happier, more productive life by treating
the other negative memories, beliefs, feelings, and actions
that may be running my life?
Source: EMDR
Network
The two most widely respected professional organizations for
EMDR are the EMDR
International Association and the EMDR
Institute. Both organizations list certified and trained
therapists on their websites who have met the necessary requirements
to provide EMDR therapy in your area. Please refer to
the references and resources below to find learn more about
EMDR.
Related links for EMDR therapy
General
information on EMDR therapy
EMDR
Frequently Asked Questions – A gateway to thorough
descriptions of EMDR therapy, synopses of research studies
on EMDR’s effectiveness, clinician training information,
and information on finding a therapist in your state. (EMDR
Institute)
Francine
Shapiro on EMDR – An interview with the originator
of EMDR. (New Therapist Magazine)
About
EMDR and EMDR & PTSD – Brief,
easy-to-understand articles (Carol Corcoran, LCMFT, LMFT
and EMDRIA Certified Therapist)
Finding an EMDR therapist
EMDRIA – Find
a Therapist – A searchable directory of EMDR International
Association certified professionals. (EMDR International
Association)
Choosing
an EMDR Clinician – Allows you to search by city
and state; offers criteria for selecting a therapist. (EMDR
Institute)
EMDR Articles
EMDR:
Taking a closer look – Presents a more skeptical
view of EMDR, comparing it to other traditional therapies
(Scientific American)
Pro
and Con: EMDR for Traumatized Children – A point-counterpoint
discussion on the use of EMDR on children. (Child Survivor
News)
Innovative
therapy helps people move beyond the disturbing effects of
trauma – Article concerning EMDR and post-traumatic
stress disorder (PTSD), especially for those in the military.
(Amherst Bulletin)
Suzanne Bartson wrote this article with editing
by Carol
Corcoran, LCMFT, LMFT, an EMDRIA Certified
Therapist.. Last modified on: 1/23/08