Advance Health Care Directives and Living Wills
Making the Best End-of-Life Choices for You and Your FamilyIn This Article
Although death is an inevitable part of life, many of us are reluctant to face the fact that we're not going to live forever and plan for our end-of-life care. Thinking about your end-of-life choices today can improve your quality of life in the future and ease the burden on your family. Discussing your wishes with loved ones and preparing an Advance Health Care Directive offers the best assurance that decisions regarding your future medical care will reflect your own values and desires.
An Advance Health Care Directive (AHCD) is a generic term for a document that instructs others about your medical care should you be unable to make decisions on your own. It only becomes effective under the circumstances delineated in the document, and allows you to do either or both of the following:
- Appoint a health care agent. The AHCD allows you to appoint a health care agent (also known as “Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care,” “Health Care Proxy,” or “attorney-in-fact”), who will have the legal authority to make health care decisions for you if you are no longer able to speak for yourself. This is typically a spouse, but can be another family member, close friend, or anyone else you feel will see that your wishes and expectations are met. The individual named will have authority to make decisions regarding artificial nutrition and hydration and any other measures that prolong life—or not.
- Prepare instructions for health care. The AHCD allows you to make specific written instructions for your future health care in the event of any situation in which you can no longer speak for yourself. Otherwise known as a “Living Will,” it outlines your wishes about life-sustaining medical treatment if you are terminally ill or permanently unconscious, for example.
The Advance Health Care Directive provides a clear statement of wishes about your choice to prolong your life or to withhold or withdraw treatment. You can also choose to request relief from pain even if doing so hastens death. A standard advance directive form provides room to state additional wishes and directions and allows you to leave instructions about organ donations.
|Misconceptions about Advance Health Care Directives|
You must have an Advance Health Care Directive to stop treatment near the end of life.
Treatment can be stopped without an advance directive if everyone involved agrees. However, without some kind of advance directive, decisions may be more difficult and disputes more likely.
An advance directive means “Do not treat.”
An advance directive can express both what you want and don’t want. Even if you do not want treatment to cure you, you should always be kept reasonably pain free and comfortable.
If I name a health care proxy, I give up the right to make my own decisions.
Naming a health care proxy or agent does not take away any of your authority. You always have the right, while you are still competent, to override the decision of your proxy or revoke the directive.
I should wait until I am sure about what I want before signing an advance directive.
Most of us have some ambivalence about what we would want because treatment near the end of life can be complicated. Advance Health Care Directives can be changed if/when your wishes or circumstances change.
Advance directives are only for old people.
Younger adults actually have more at stake, because, if stricken by serious disease or accident, medical technology may keep them alive but insentient for decades. Every person aged 18 or over should prepare a directive.
Source: American Bar Association
While most people would prefer to die in their own homes, the norm is still for terminally-ill patients to die in the hospital, often receiving ineffective treatments that they may not really want. Their friends and family members can become embroiled in bitter arguments about the best way to care for the patient and consequently miss sharing the final stage of life with their loved one. Also, the opinions and wishes of the dying person are often lost in all the chaos.
It’s almost impossible to know what a dying person’s wishes truly are unless the issues have been discussed ahead of time. Planning ahead with an Advance Health Care Directive can give your principal caregiver, family members, and other loved ones peace of mind when it comes to making decisions about your future health care. It lets everyone know what is important to you, and what is not. Talking about death with those close to us is not about being ghoulish or giving up on life, but a way to ensure greater quality of life, even when faced with a life-limiting illness or tragic accident. When your loved ones are clear about your preferences for treatment, they’re free to devote their energy to care and compassion.
End-of-life issues in an Advance Health Care Directive
Specific issues relate to the end of one's life. These include:
- Whom do you want to make decisions for you if you are not able to make your own, both on financial matters and health care decisions? The same person may not be right for both.
- What medical treatments and care are acceptable to you? Are there some that you fear?
- Do you wish to be resuscitated if you stop breathing and/or your heart stops?
- Do you want to be hospitalized or stay at home, or somewhere else, if you are seriously or terminally ill?
- How will your care be paid for? Do you have adequate insurance? What might you have overlooked that will be costly at a time when your loved ones are distracted by grieving over your condition or death?
- What actually happens when a person dies? Do you want to know more about what might happen? Will your loved ones be prepared for the decisions they may have to make?
Source: Family Caregiver Alliance
Advance Health Care Directives and living wills are not complicated, but the content can be complex and should be thought through very carefully. It can be short, simple statements about what you want done or not done if you can't speak for yourself. It’s important to discuss your wishes with family members, legal, health or other appropriate professionals when preparing such a document. It is particularly important to talk with everyone who might be involved about your wishes because in times of stress, others may confuse their own wishes with your wishes.
In the U.S., most state governments have designed forms for people to complete on their own by filling in the blanks. While these are not usually mandatory, most states do require witnessing or other specific signing formalities. Anything you write by yourself or with a computer software package should follow your state laws. So, it’s essential for you to know what the laws are in your state. See the Resources section below to find out about your state’s laws. While you are not required to seek legal advice to prepare an advance health care directive, it may be a good idea to do so to ensure that the actual instructions for your wishes are stated accurately. It has to be absolutely clear to be enforceable.
Advance Health Care Directive forms
Advance Health Care Directive forms for your state are available via:
- State healthcare association website.
- Community and senior services organizations.
- Attorneys handling wills, estates, probate, and Elderlaw matters.
- Geriatric care managers.
- Hospitals or hospice programs.
Speak With Your Physician
It is important that you discuss your health care desires with your physician. He or she is likely to be the one caring for you when your instructions become relevant and is much more likely to honor requests that have been communicated directly. Your physician can:
- Help you phrase your requests in a way that makes sense to medical professionals and can answer any questions you may have.
- Point out any illogical or inconsistent features of your requests. Sometimes refusing one kind of treatment makes it illogical to expect to receive another kind of treatment. Your physician can smooth out some of these "rough edges" and help make a consistent and coherent directive.
- Tell you if there are aspects of your requests that he or she cannot honor because of personal, moral, or professional constraints.
Speak With Your Family
Despite your best efforts to plan for all eventualities in a health care declaration, actual events may not "fit" your directives. It is therefore important that you discuss your desires with family and friends.
- Your family can often help clarify your directives on the basis of recollections of specific discussions under specific circumstances.
- If you have discussed your wishes with a number of people, it is more likely that those wishes will be honored.
- Discussions with family members can help avoid unpleasant scenes and confrontations when you are incapacitated. While family members may have little legal authority to make decisions for incapacitated patients, they often feel they have moral authority. They may be confused by statements not previously shared with them, and may even try to contest your wishes legally if they feel your choices are not in your "best interest."
Source: The Living Will: A Guide To Health Care Decision Making (SUNY, Buffalo)
To ensure that your future care wishes are understood and respected by all those who are important to you, it’s imperative that you sit down and talk to your family and loved ones about your end-of-life choices. For many of us, the prospect of such a conversation can seem like a daunting task. You or your loved ones may be uncomfortable talking about serious illness or death, or it may seem “too soon” to have a conversation about end-of-life preparations. However, it’s better to have the conversation when you and your loved ones are in a calm and relaxed state, rather than in the midst of a medical emergency when everyone’s stressed and it’s difficult to think clearly.
While you may think that your loved ones already know what you want, the truth is there is often a startling difference between what people say they want and what their family members think they want. The only way to be certain that your loved ones understand your wishes is to sit down and have the conversation.
- Choose a time and place where you and your loved ones feel comfortable and at ease, such as after a family dinner, on a walk, or sitting outside in the sun.
- Not everything has to be discussed at once. The conversation can be spread out over different times.
- Be patient with your loved ones. Fear and denial are common. Some people need longer to become comfortable talking about dying, others may have different feelings about what end-of-life plans should involve.
- Don’t feel like you can never change your mind. Your opinions and wishes can change over time and Advance Health Care Directives can be revised.
How to get started
You can get started by sending your loved ones a copy of this article with a note saying, “I’d like to talk about this.”
Other ways you could break the ice:
- Remember how someone in the family died—was it a “good” death or a “hard” death? How will yours be different? “I was thinking about what happened to (Uncle Joe), and it made me realize…”
- “Even though I’m okay right now, I’m worried that (I’ll get sick), and I want to be prepared.”
- “I need to think about the future. Will you help me?”
- “I just answered some questions about how I want the end of my life to be. I want you to see my answers. And I’m wondering what your answers would be.”
You may hit some roadblocks once you embark on the process of planning an Advance Health Care Directive. Here are some common pitfall scenarios with tips on how to avoid them.
Failing to choose a health care agent
The pitfall: Peter and Chris had been loving partners for four years. They talked about practically everything under the sun. One day, Peter had a car accident that sent him to the hospital with serious injuries. Because they weren’t married, Chris could see Peter only during visiting hours. Much worse, Chris didn’t have the authority to make important decisions for Peter’s care, which fell instead to Peter’s only living relative, a sister. She lived on the other side of the country and wasn’t at all close to Peter or Chris. This could have been avoided if Peter had designated Chris as his health care agent.
The fix: Choose a health care agent and fill out the form. If you change your mind at a later date, you can name a different agent.
Not properly describing your wishes, or making your wishes too specific
The pitfall: Rashid told Ellen he would never want to be on a ventilator, even if he was seriously ill, because his father had spent the last days of his life “hooked up to machines.” Then he had a bad accident at work and ended up hospitalized, in a coma. His prognosis was reasonably good—the doctors felt it was likely he would come out of it.
There was a catch, though. When Rashid was taken to the hospital, he was unconscious, and no one knew his wishes. His heart and breathing stopped, so CPR was performed. To stabilize him, the emergency team put him on a ventilator before Ellen arrived with a copy of Rashid’s health care power of attorney. Ellen knew Rashid never wanted to be on a ventilator. However, she also realized that if Rashid had understood that a ventilator could be a bridge to a full recovery, he might have been more flexible in his wishes. Now she had to determine whether to have the doctors take him off the ventilator.
The fix: Avoid absolute instructions about specific treatments unless you are currently approaching a decision about the specific treatment. You might not fully understand the medical terms and implications of your choices. Have a conversation with your doctor as well as your health care agent about what you really want. A dialogue is more likely to turn up “what if” questions: What if a ventilator were needed as a bridge to recovery? Would it be all right to use it for a trial period if doctors thought it might help you regain consciousness?
Adapted with permission from Living Wills, a special health report published by Harvard Health Publications.
Once you have completed your advance directive, it may be necessary to have it notarized depending on who witnesses your signature—follow the instructions on the document in accordance with your state laws. Providing many trusted individuals with copies of your advance directive will insure that your health care wishes are met in the event that you cannot express your wishes for yourself.
Keep the original copy of the Advance Health Care Directive yourself in a place that can easily be found, and give copies to:
- Your chosen health care proxy (with directions on where to find the original).
- Family members or other loved ones.
- Your primary care physician, hospital, or health care institution. Ask that a copy is placed in your medical record and make sure your doctor will support your wishes.
- Anyone named in the directive.
A copy can also be sent to your attorney or kept in a safety deposit box or anywhere else you may keep copies of a will or other important papers. Be sure that you have discussed the directive with the person you designate as your health care agent and that he or she understands your wishes and the responsibilities involved.
It’s best to think of Advance Health Care Directives as a work in progress. Circumstances can change, as can your values and opinions about how you would best like your future health care needs to be met. Directives can be revoked or replaced at any time as long as you are capable of making your own decisions. It is recommended that you review your documents every few years or after important life changes and revise your directives to ensure that they continue to accurately reflect your situation and wishes.
When to Reassess Your Advance Health Care Directive
Re-examine your health care wishes every few years or whenever any of the “Five D’s” occur:
- Decade – when you start each new decade of your life.
- Death – whenever you experience the death of a loved one.
- Divorce – when you experience a divorce or other major family change.
- Diagnosis – when you are diagnosed with a serious health condition.
- Decline – when you experience a significant decline or deterioration of an existing health condition, especially when it diminishes your ability to live independently.
Source: American Bar Association
Choices about end of life are important for all adults—not just for the older population. Not only does an Advance Health Care Directive let your voice be heard about what you want, but it also relieves others of making these decisions for you.
Changing your Advance Health Care Directive
If your current Advance Health Care Directive no longer reflects your wishes for end-of-life care, refer to your state’s laws for the correct way to cancel or amend your existing advance directive. Once you have revised your Advance Health Care Directive, it is important to discuss the changes with your physician and family members, and notify everyone who has copies of your old directive forms.
More help for end-of-life issues
- Dementia and Alzheimer's: Symptoms, Stages, Diagnosis, and Coping Tips
- Late Stage and End-of-Life Care: Caregiving in the Final Stages of Life
- Hospice and Palliative Care: Quality of Life at the End of Life
- Deciding on Your Wishes for Care: Understanding the Medical Terms Used in Living Wills
Resources and references
The Living Will: A Guide To Health Care Decision Making – Article by a physician and attorney addresses difficult issues including Terminal Illness, Permanent Disability, Determining Permanence or Irreversibility, Ordinary and Extraordinary Care. (University of Buffalo)
Myths and Facts About Health Care Advance Directives (PDF) – A list of common myths about advance directives and the fcts that dispel them. (American Bar Association Commission on Law and Aging)
Your Living Will: The New Advance Health Care Directive – A comprehensive list of questions and answers regarding California advance health care directives. (California Medical Association)
Consumer’s Tool Kit for Health Care Advance Planning – Contains 10 “tools” (PDF documents) that provide a variety of self-help worksheets, suggestions, and resources to help you “discover, clarify, and communicate” what is important to you in the face of serious illness. (American Bar Association Commission on Law and Aging)
End-of-Life Decision-Making – Outlines issues to consider when you or a loved one is faced with end-of life decision-making and provides resources for additional assistance. (Family Caregiver Alliance)
Advance Health Care Directive Forms
Five Wishes – Very popular document helps you express how you want to be treated if you are seriously ill and unable to speak for yourself. Addresses medical, personal, emotional, and spiritual needs. Also encourages discussing your wishes with your family and physician. "Non-printable" version is free; $5 charge for printable version (Aging with Dignity)
Caring Connections – Offers consumer information and state-by-state advance directive forms. (NHPCO)
U.S. Living Will Registry – Offers state-by-state advance directive forms. (U.S. Living Will Registry)